Edifier M3600d vs. Logitech Z623


Edifier M3600d vs. Logitech Z623

We’ve researched Edifier M3600D and Logitech Z623 extensively, and after testing both the Edifier M3600D and Logitech Z623  with varying gaming surround sound system setups we’ve determined that the new Edifier M3600D is the best value and a good surround sound speaker for gaming, tv watching and online music streaming.

Edifier USA M3600D Multimedia 2.1 Active Speaker System - THX Certified - 200 Watts RMS Black (4003332)

$222.75  in stock
Amazon.com
as of August 25, 2021 8:52 pm

Features

  • THX Certified
  • 200 WATT RMS - 130 Watt RMS subwoofer plus 2- 35 Watt/channel RMS satellites
  • MDF cabinet with high quality vinyl wood grain laminate
  • INPUTS - optical, coaxial, line in, AUX
  • 2 YEAR WARRANTY - hassle free full replacement warranty in USA and Canada

If you want to go a step farther, the Swans Speakers are an excellent gaming speaker option too. These bad boys boast of – M200 DSP, and they are also aesthetically pleasing to look at your work station. Despite being a set of Powered 2.0 Wireless Bookshelf Speakers, they are ideal for all applications you can hope for in ultra-modern – HiFi Speakers with a thumping 28mm Cat Eye Dome Tweeters.

Swans Speakers - M3AMKII - Powered 2.0 Bookshelf Speaker, 3-Way Acoustic Design, Individual Analog Amplifiers, RMS 120Wx2, Supporting Wi-Fi/Bluetooth aptX HD, Handcrafted Solid Wood Enclosures.

 out of stock
Amazon.com
as of August 25, 2021 8:52 pm

Features

  • Advanced Acoustic System--The 3-Way electroacoustic design provides greater dynamic range and less distortion;
  • Premium Drivers--The midrange driver is covered with damping coating which makes the sound pretty sweet; The isodynamic ribbon tweeter has high resolution that can convey voice clearly;
  • Indvidual Analog Amplifiers--Each channel has a built-in analog amplifier specially designed for this model,so this pair of speakers has rated power of RMS 120W×2 and Hi-Fi sound quality;
  • Various Interfaces--A complete set of input interfaces including Wi-Fi/ LAN/Bluetooth/Balanced XLR/Optical and line input;
  • Solid Wood Cabinets--Cabinets made of solid wood provide sense of luxury, as well as low resonance and low diffraction, making the sound clearer.

But that’s not all! Swans speakers also come with a 5.25” Midbass Drivers – 80W
nearly everything a pro-gamer would ask for in the absence of audio-video receivers can be expensive and too technical to set up.

Unlike other desktop gaming speakers, the Edifier M3600D comes packed with advanced pro gamer’s digital audio technology needs in mind. These speakers are a low power consumption gaming accessory to have. They are also hardened with built-in high-efficiency D class digital amplifiers, which is a bonus, and with that, you can bet an effortless output total 200W RMS.

On the other hand, the Logitech Z623 Speaker System also doesn’t disappoint! They may look unsuspecting and kind of an underdog, but Logitech’s Z623 delivers 200 watts (RMS) of power in a THX-Certified system for big, bold gaming or audio streaming experience.

The Edifier M3600D and the Logitech Z623 are one of the best speakers that were made for home and gaming usage. Whether you are gaming or watching a movie, the Edifier M3600d and Logitech Z623 are a perfect match for your exhilarating audio experience and the best sound quality.

Edifier M3600D

When you think of versatility, think of the Edifier 3600D speakers. Whether you want to play your games or simply want to grab some popcorn and watch your favorite movie, the Edifier M3600D will always deliver quality sound with clarity and a seamless way without clutter.

There are so many reasons to love these speakers. They come with an advanced digital audio technology, a D class digital amplifier, which is said to output the total power of 200W RMS. Also, you can take advantage of low power consumption.

On top of that, they have a 2.1 surround system that features an 8-inch subwoofer producing an output of 130 Watts. In terms of the build material, these M3600D speakers have an MDF satellite, which makes a stable speaker.
What’s more, you will have a stress-free installation. The come with a highly-detailed user manual, which makes the installation incredibly easy.

Design
The Edifier speaker set comes with an exquisite design. Let’s look at each of the components one by one.
Right satellite speaker.
The right speaker is considered to be an active speaker. It has a knob that allows you to either increase/decrease the volume. When you press this knob, it switches you to a different mode or input.
While the right speaker has the volume adjustment, it doesn’t feature the bass adjustment. This is only found on the right side of the subwoofer itself.
Left satellite speaker. 
Measuring at 8 inches, the right speaker doesn’t have any customizable controls. It features a thin cloth that covers the driver. In this way, the speaker driver is protected from being touched or poked.

The speaker interface (audio inputs) 

You have a speaker interface that is found on the rear end of the subwoofer. This part contains the ports, which you can utilize to connect in your left and right satellite speakers.

As a tip, you should connect the cables from the two satellite speakers to the subwoofer, instead of connecting one satellite speaker to the other (left to right or vice versa). The subwoofer speaker is protected with a metal grill, which makes a very durable piece.

On the side of the subwoofer, you have a coaxial input, an optical input as well as multiple auxiliary inputs.
Speaking of connectivity, however, this speaker does not offer a wireless Bluetooth feature, so everything uses a wired connection. This side of the subwoofer contains the control panel on which you will find the bass adjustment knob.

Lastly, you have a porthole on the right of the subwoofer. This gives you a firm grip, hence making it easy to carry it around.

Performance

The Edifier speakers have a THX Certified 2.1 Multimedia Speaker System, which is geared towards giving you a more balanced sound.

But, you will still have some issues with the clarity of these speakers- since a small speaker usually obviously means a small driver to produce the sound.
That being said, the frequencies (highs, mids and lows) are restricted to a certain extent, so at some volumes, you may not be able to hear some musical instruments.

This speaker is somehow similar to the Edifier S350B model, particularly the sound projection technology. Instead of being held back, the music feels like it is projected in your direction.
With that said, these are directional speakers, so you will probably need to set them up so they should be facing you in order to get the best from them.

Plus, they are already tilted to about 10 degrees, which goes a long way to ensure that every sound reaches your ear.
Unlike most speakers, these speakers do not come with customizable knobs for your bass, so you will have the task of getting under your desk or pulling your satellite speaker out just to adjust your bass settings. Also, you don’t have a remote control.

Another downfall comes from the fact that you are not provided with a Toslink optical audio cable.
If you aren’t familiar with it, this is the cable that connects your audio source to the subwoofers optical input.

Although this cable may be considered as an optional piece to use, it is a very important cable as it will turn this speaker set into a versatile sound machine for the whole family to enjoy. After all, the best family speakers are the ones that come with several connectivity features.

This means you will have to spend more time and money to purchase that cable, which is very inconvenient.

What’s in the box? 

In the packaging, you have two stereo-enhanced speakers and a powerful subwoofer. Also you have the 3.5 mm RCA input cable which connects your speakers to your phone or computer. This cable measures at 1.7 meters in length.

Logitech Z623

On the other hand, we have the Logitech Z623 model. This speaker is known to be the best gaming speaker for professional gamers, particularly PC gamers. Also, its enhanced audio features make it an excellent choice for music and movies.

At a price such a low cost, this speaker comes at an incredibly more economical price, which makes it an ideal choice for gamers on a slimmer budget. 

Logitech Z623 400 Watt Home Speaker System, 2.1 Speaker System - Black

$149.99
$119.99
 in stock
8 used from $74.99
Free shipping
Amazon.com
as of August 25, 2021 8:52 pm

Features

  • THX-certified 2.1 speaker system brings your music, movies and games to life in immersive studio-quality audio; Satellites: 2 x 35 Watt
  • RCA and 3.5 millimeter inputs make it easy to plug in up to 3 audio devices - your computer, iPod, game console, DVD player and more
  • 2 satellite speakers and a powerful subwoofer deliver sound big enough to fill even large entertainment rooms.Please Note: Kindly refer the User Guide before use.
  • Compatible with Television,Computer,Smartphone,Tablet,Music player,DVD player,Blu-ray player,PlayStation,Xbox,Wii. System Requirements: Works with any device with either a headphone jack (3.5 millimeter) or RCA input.
  • 400 Watts Peak/200 Watts RMS power delivers amped audio from this 2.1 speaker system. Subwoofer-130 W. Dimensions( H x W x D)-Subwoofer-11.2 x 12.0 x 10.5 inches. Right Satellite-7.7 x 4.6 x 5.0 inches. Left Satellite-7.7 x 4.6 x 5.0 inches

Logitech Speaker System Z623 delivers 200 watts (RMS) of power. Multiple inputs let you connect your music, movie, and gaming devices. Also, the model has a THX-Certified system.
Overall, this speaker offers the best sound quality, thus allowing you to enjoy your game- whichever game that may be. Also, it comes at a good size, which means it will fit into just about any room. On top of that, it offers the best 2.1 surround sound system.

Design

In terms of the size, you this is probably one of the smallest ones you will ever set your eyes one- but don’t let the size fool you. The amount of bass that these speakers produce will definitely blow some gaming speakers out of the water.
Besides the size, this speaker has a really cool look that will give your room an elegant experience. In terms of the dimensions, the Logitech’s subwoofer measures 11 inches x 12 inches x 10 inches and weighs about 15.4 pounds. It also has comes with two speakers, both of which measure at 7.7 inches x 4.6 inches 5 5 inches and have a weigh of about 2.2 pounds.

On the right speaker, you have the control panel, which you can use to adjust the volume as well as the bass. Also, this component connects to the subwoofer using a durable cable. The two 3.5 mm ports allow you to connect this speaker to your PC, smartphone or any other device that has the 3.5 jack, including some gaming consoles.

Performance

As I said before, this Logitech offers a very good performance. In fact, it has the best third dimensional 2.1 surround system you can ever find.

With a 400 Watt peak power, the Logitech Z623 are among the most dominant speakers you can find. They have met strict performance standards to achieve THX certification.
With that said, it provides a perfectly balanced bass and treble. The customizability allows you to adjust them the way you want.

Another great feature that you is the power controls. Once connected to your PC, you have the power controls right on your PCs, which means you don’t ever have to leave your gaming chair to power the speaker up.
What’s in the box?
The Logitech Z623 comes with two speakers as well as a subwoofer. In addition to these three components, you are provided with a 3.5 mm audio input cable and all the necessary speaker cables. To help you set everything up, you are provided with a user manual.

Summary

Characteristic

  1. Brand
  2. Model
  3. Origin

Edifier M3600D

  • Edifier
  • M3600D
  • China

 

Logitech Z623

  • Logitech
  • Z623
  • China

Characteristic

  1. Material
  2. Color
  3. Height
  4. Width

Edifier M3600D

  • Plastic/MDF
  • Black
  • 12.6 inches
  • 18 inches

 

Logitech Z623

  • Plastic
  • Black
  • 7.7 inches
  • 4.6 inches

Sensitivity

In speakers, sensitivity measures the speaker’s ability to convert power to volume. Lower sensitivity speakers require more power from the amplifier to achieve higher volumes. 

With this theory, speakers that have a higher sensitivity will require less power from the amplifier. In this case, the Edifier has a sensitivity of 84dB while the Logitech Z623 has a higher sensitivity of 89 dB.

As we can see, both of these speakers have the same 2.1 surround Multimedia system type and the same power characteristics. Nonetheless, the Edifier M3600D comes with more input options as compared to the Logitech Z623 speaker system. 

Eddie Mcfarren

Eddie Mcfarren is an avid blogger and audio enthusiast who enjoys a relatively long list of hobbies from Listening to music, backyard gardening to creating small scale businesses in varying niche markets. When he is not writing about the best gaming guides, he is probably researching best pet care tips for his pet dog (Tess the Staffordshire Terrier). Or he is busy researching what skincare products work best for his daughter, who, as a mixed-race, has combination skin type. He is crazy about retirement money saving using alternative revenue streams. You can link up with him via twitter or LinkedIn. In his, on words, he says, "I know that not all retirement goals are equal, so, regardless of your goals being a lifestyle change, money-saving or emergency preparedness, now is time to find tools and ways that work best for your retirement-saving and go to work!". He is an SEO expert and publisher who runs an independently owned and operated publishing business from the northwest Greater Manchester in the United Kingdom. His business model is primarily supported through affiliate programs and digital product creation.

Recent Posts